Understanding the buyer’s journey is more significant than ever. With immense competition at every turn, consumers have hundreds of options daily, making the path to purchase far from straightforward. Instead, it’s more akin to a maze, with different journeys, many dead ends, and a vast and messy middle. It’s the ‘messy middle’ where businesses often lose potential customers.
Let’s journey deep into the buyer’s psyche to demystify this complex process and break down core aspects that encapsulate the ‘messy middle’ and explore the overarching loop of the buyer’s journey.
1. The Exploration Phase
At the very beginning of the buyer’s journey is the exploration phase, which begins to form after preexisting thoughts and ideas about anticipated needs or preferences arise. This initial stage is where potential customers realize a need or problem and begin the search for a solution. As they start discovering and gathering information, they typically encounter multiple options. And here lies a big problem — information overload.
Although having multiple options may seem helpful, encountering many choices can lead to decision paralysis, making consumers feel lost in the ‘messy middle.’ At this point, most consumers either delay or abandon their search, and understanding this problem in the marketplace opens the doors for businesses to capitalize on this opportunity.
Tip: Curate a seamless discovery experience
Consider guiding consumers through this phase by providing a streamlined and intuitive discovery experience, which involves delivering clear, concise, and compelling information about your products or services. For example, companies can do this by addressing commonly asked questions upfront and providing user-friendly website navigation. The more accessible businesses can make the exploration process, the better the chances of a customer staying in your loop.
Image Source: Think with Google
2. Evaluation and Decision-Making
Once consumers gather enough information, they enter the next phase: evaluation and decision-making. During this phase, they begin to weigh their options, compare different solutions, and inch closer and closer to making a purchase. This phase is often cluttered with options, constant complex comparisons, numerous factors, and variables to weigh — all adding to the complexity of the ‘messy middle.’
Tip: Simplify the evaluation process
Businesses can ease this decision-making process by presenting their value proposition. For example:
- Provide clear and comparable information about your offerings.
- If your competitors share additional details about their products/services, consider replicating some of their tactics to test on your site and assess the impact of competitive adjustments.
- Highlight the unique features and benefits of your product or service. In other words, showcase how your product or service is better than your competitors.
The goal is to make yourself stand out from your competition, and during this stage, there are plenty of opportunities to build trust with your potential customers. Trust-building elements such as testimonials and reviews act as ‘social proof,’ which are pivotal in steering the decision-making process in your favor.
3. The Looping Effect & The Post-Purchase Experience
The looping effect occurs when consumers loop through the exploration and evaluation phases of the buyer’s journey, where they seek information to compare and narrow down options before making a purchase. But the journey does not end with a purchase. As many companies tend to forget, the buyer’s journey does not stop at the time of purchase. When thinking about CLV (Customer Lifetime Value), the buyer’s journey can often extend in perpetuity forever. Think about it. After a purchase, customers evaluate their experience, influencing their perception of your brand and their likelihood to repurchase or recommend — and remember that recommendations or “word of mouth” powerfully influence purchasing decisions.
Considering the impact of recommendations on brand perception and purchasing decisions, it is essential to point out that marketing efforts are often hyperfocused on converting opportunities into customers, resulting in frequent oversight of the post-purchase experience. This oversight can often represent missed business opportunities to maintain and establish long-lasting customer relationships.
Tip: Foster post-purchase engagement
Studies show that acquiring new customers costs 6 to 7 times more than retaining existing customers. Consider implementing strategies that facilitate ongoing engagement. Personalized follow-ups, loyalty programs, and offering premium content or exclusive deals to repeat purchasers are great ways to keep customers engaged. All of these foster a sense of belonging, which customers greatly appreciate while encouraging customers to stay connected to your brand and strengthen loyalty.
4. Emotion and the ‘Messy Middle’
Lastly, one cannot underestimate the power of emotion in the buyer’s journey. Emotion very often trumps logic in decision-making, and consumers tend to purchase products and services that resonate with them at an emotional level. For this reason, creating an emotional connection with your audience is instrumental in winning the buyer during their buyer journey. However, managing emotions in the ‘messy middle’ can be tricky due to its unpredictable and often irrational nature.
Tip: Create emotional connections
There are many ways that businesses can create emotional connections with their current and potential customers. The most common and powerful tool is storytelling, which helps humanize your brand and establish a deeper connection with your audience. Brands that align their narrative with the values and aspirations of their customers are often the most successful in navigating the emotional ‘messy middle.’ Brands that can convey this in a manner that resonates with their audience are the brands that win and stand the test of time.
Summary
The buyer’s journey can be messy and complicated. However, understanding and addressing these challenges can help your business successfully navigate the ‘messy middle.’ By streamlining the exploration and evaluation process, fostering post-purchase engagement, and creating emotional connections, companies can guide customers through the loop of the buyer’s journey more effectively, thereby winning over more customers.
Remember that each interaction with a customer is an opportunity to deepen the relationship, deliver extraordinary value, and turn customers into repeat purchasers loyal to your brand. While the middle might be messy, it is also a place where your business can genuinely differentiate itself and cultivate lifelong customer relationships.